Thursday, May 23, 2013

An Ecological Material for Restoration and Construction



The innovative, original American system of straw bale construction has been warmly and increasingly embraced as a beautiful and ecologically sustainable construction alternative for France and other countries of the European Union.

Traditional French plasters have been used extensively as coatings for EU straw bale construction. The article below is based on the presentation “Plaster - An Ecological Material for Restoration and Construction” delivered by Frédéric Charpentier, consulting architect for Maisons Paysannes de France at the 2010 Bâtir Ecologique (Ecological Building) conference in Paris.

Currently, a number of coatings are utilized for straw bale construction: cob and other clay or earth based coatings, lime stuccos of varying degrees of hydraulicity as well as traditional or Portland cement. The primary need of an exterior coating is to protect the insulating straw substrate against damage by water and fire. All mineral based coatings properly applied can achieve this fundamental purpose. Additionally, an ideal coating would possess the following properties:
  • high breathability 
  • porosity  
  • fire resistance in addition to incombustibility 
  • low embodied energy 
  • ease of installation 
  • a beautiful aesthetic
Traditional French plasters such as Stuc Pierre and Terre de Séléné exhibit the above characteristics. The importance of breathability, the capacity of a coating to transmit water vapor, is widely known for monolithic substrate construction. Often less understood are the benefits of a porous coating. To be sure, guidelines are to be followed to prevent water migration due to capillary action; however, the porosity of gypsum allows for the evacuation of condensation or water penetration caused by structural cracks or extensive inundation.

As with all mineral based coatings, gypsum is a non-combustible material. However gypsum plaster, technically known as calcium sulfate hemi-hydrate when combined with water, returns to gypsum or calcium sulfate dihydrate (CaSO4·2H2O) chemically combining calcium sulfate with two water molecules. When exposed to fire, a wall coated with gypsum plaster will release water vapor which retards the spread of fire and maintains the temperature in the adjoining room less than 350°F thus inhibiting the spread of fire via spontaneous combustion and often starving the fire through lack of oxygen. In this way gypsum plaster is not just incombustible but actively functions as a fire retardant.

This same chemical property of raw gypsum allows the manufacture of gypsum plaster to be achieved at comparatively low temperatures. Typically gypsum is baked in a horizontal kiln at the relatively low temperature of under 500°F for a couple of hours under autoclave conditions to create plaster. This is considerably less than the embodied energy expended in lime (1500°F) or Portland cement (2700°F) stuccos. Unlike hydraulic limes and cements, gypsum coatings can be removed and recycled as a plaster.

Another property of gypsum plaster is that it is lightweight and self binding. Average weights of coatings are between 5 to 6 lb per ft² at 1 inch thickness. As added water is bound chemically in the set there is no shrinkage of the coating and no need for sanded aggregates to bind the material. For this reason gypsum plaster can be applied as thick as 1 ½” in a single coat. The set is reached in a few hours. As a result, plaster can be applied so long as there is not a frost the same day. Plaster is first applied as a scratch coat directly over straw bale or lathe to a thickness necessary to fill in the inconsistencies of the substrate. The rapidity of set also permits a subsequent coat to be applied the following day. Generally this can be applied at less than 1” thickness to achieve a planar surface. In Europe, wool wood sheathing such as Fibralith is often utilized to supplement insulating performance and eliminate the need for a scratch coat. This relative ease of application is an attractive quality for both professionals and DIY’s.
 
Not to be forgotten is a most important aspect of sustainability; beauty. The surface of the plaster can be finished with scraped, sanded, washed or even ashlar cut techniques so as to appear like limestone block. Running and casting versions can be utilized for running cornices, adding quoins and decorative ornamentation. Often shells, chaulk, limestone, shale and straw are added in the finish coat for strictly aesthetic effect.

French plaster is a proven coating technology that has been utilized for centuries in hundreds of thousands of buildings in Paris, Normandy, Toulouse and throughout Europe.
The Vieujot family has maintained continual manufacturer of gypsum plaster of Paris since 1880. In 1996 Plâtres Vieujot established Plâtre.com to better serve the market for decorative, ecological and restoration coatings of gypsum, clay, hydraulic and aérienne lime.

Contributed by Patrick Webb

US Technical Consultant
Plâtres Vieujot
patrick.webb@platre.com

Sunday, May 12, 2013

The American College of the Building Arts



Speaking from personal experience, I can say that my own plastering education was a major challenge to undertake. Due to the general decline of the trade in the 1940’s the apprenticeship programs supported in plaster shops and by the unions largely disappeared. By the 1980’s only a handful of old timers were around and most of them were jealously guarding their knowledge for fear of losing the limited available work to a younger generation. However, if you were respectful, courteous and patient there were a few gems to extract.

Beginning in the 1990’s plaster began making a slow and steady return to architectural specification in the luxury residential, public/institutional, restoration and natural building sectors. Nevertheless, the training infrastructure that formerly existed remains to be rebuilt and this is a significant factor that has hampered its growth.

Yet there is reason for encouragement for the future of plaster education. In North America, plaster unions have been placing an increased emphasis on fundamental plaster education for their members and a vocational Job Corps pre-apprenticeship program designed to introduce young people to the trade. European institutions such as Les Compagnons in France and Il Centro Europeo Per i Mestieri del Patrimonio in Italy are working hard to keep the trades vibrant in their countries and have an increased program of outreach with related institutions around the world.

ACBA
 
I would like to introduce a preeminent institution right here in the US dedicated to the artisan and the heritage building arts. The college combines theory and practice into a 4 year Bachelor degree program. Their mission is well articulated in the following statement:


“The American College of the Building Arts educates and trains artisans in the traditional building arts to foster exceptional craftsmanship and encourage the preservation, enrichment, and understanding of the world's architectural heritage through a liberal arts education.”

I have been privileged to support this institution in the past as a guest lecturer and sponsor of the annual Master of the Building Arts festival. It was an honor to be offered the position of Adjunct Professor of Plaster Working at the college and I look forward to rolling up my sleeves for the fall semester of 2013 engaging students in theory and practice.

Theory

Plaster traditionally has been considered an allied art to the field of architecture. Quite logically, the artisan should have a high level proficiency in architectural language. This is accomplished at ACBA through a core curriculum of Classical Architecture. There are several courses on architectural history, philosophy and design. Drawing, sketching, hand drafting are all requisite studies. Only after these skills have been mastered do students learn CAD as a communication not a design tool.

Academics such as English, foreign language, math and science are combined into a unified program of study shared by all students, tailored to support practical applications of the heritage trades. A total of 12 credit hours per semester are dedicated to theory and academics.

Practice

Plaster as any of the building trades is largely a tactile experience. Theory is put to practice daily under the guidance of experienced artisans. The freshman and sophomore years outline a combined study of brick masonry, architectural stone carving and flat plasterwork. This cross training in the “trowel trades” gives a strong foundation for the junior and senior years of specialization that for plaster includes mouldings and ornament.

In addition to the 6 credit hours of institutional practice per semester, 8-10 week summer internships are mandatory. Students have already been equipped with a fundamental level of trade knowledge and are placed so as to be an asset to the company they work with. 


Liaisons and Continuing Education

Exchange with plasterers and plaster companies, plaster manufacturers, related institutions, plaster unions are all very important for the students and the college itself. Please do not hesitate to contact us if you have an interest in taking on an intern, sponsoring an event or creating a dialogue in regard to trade education.

As part of their commitment to outreach and development of the building arts, programs of continuing education for working professionals based at the college are being organized for the spring of 2014.


An overview of the Trowel Trades program including Plaster Working:
http://buildingartscollege.us/?page_id=1852


Interested in more content on a Philosophy of Craft?
Please visit my YouTube channel: A Craftsman's Philosophy


Contributed by Patrick Webb

Friday, December 28, 2012

Moroccan Tadelakt



Sgrafitto by a "Mâalem", master plasterer 
Enigmatic, exotic, artisanal, rustic, seductive…just a few of the adjectives that attempt to capture the essence of Tadelakt, the plaster of Marrakech that has in recent years fascinated the imagination of the Western design world, first in France (logically as Morocco is French speaking and a popular destination for holiday and vacation homes. Also, many French designers I must admit have impeccable taste) and subsequently throughout the EU and US. A number of years ago I accompanied a team from Venice organized by a true master of the Italian tradition, Franco Saladino, to study Tadelakt application and manufacture. I immediately fell in love with the food, the music, the “terroir”, the culture and of course the plasterwork. One of my plaster colleagues in the US, Ryan Chivers, made a similar visit and was likewise enthralled. Ryan and I will do our best to share what we’ve learned of its history, manufacture and application.

History

Tadelakt lined cistern, Al Badi palace
The word Tadelakt is an English transliteration of the Arabic “تدلاكت”, meaning “massaged” or alternatively “rubbed”, “kneaded”. The name is meaningful and a big hint to what Tadelakt is all about. Yes, it is a type of plaster that has certain properties but more significantly it is a traditional practice of application that involves a bit of elbow grease. Lime burning for plaster has been going on for a long time in North Africa. We know Egypt for example was using gypsum and lime plasters for the construction of the pyramids and other structures dating back 5,000 years ago. However, it was under the Almoravid “Berber” dynasty of the 11th century based in Marrakech that artisans began to use the Tadelakt method of finishing the locally produced lime to waterproof the royal cisterns.

The limestone used to produce Tadelakt comes from the High Atlas Mountains to the east. The limestone is argillaceous, meaning it contains a relatively high percentage clay. Also, there is a small infiltration of amorphous silica making Tadelakt lime slightly hydraulic. Combining its natural properties with traditional application methods Tadelakt’s waterproofing qualities were subsequently put to decorative use in exterior façades, small drinking vessels and famously the “hammams” or public bath houses.

Manufacture

The open pit
The Tadelakt "factories" are found at the foothills of the High Atlas Mountains. The factories are little more than a flat stretch of land with a series of cylindrical pits lined with adobe bricks. Each pit has a tight tunnel entrance leading to the floor of the pit so fuel can be added during the baking. The limestone is broken down to more or less grapefruit-sized pieces. There is no mechanical equipment so all the work is done by hand breaking one stone against another. Then a vault is carefully arranged by hand over the pit. It is very important that the size of the stones are the same so that there is an even baking. Too large and the carbon will not be completely driven off. Too small and there is a vitrification of the silicates. Either way you can end up with a lot of useless chunks.

The vault constructed, ready for baking
This is precisely the same process outlined by Vitruvius and utilized by the Romans two millennia ago to produce lime plaster. The Arabs had preserved many of the old Roman texts and during their golden age translated many Greek and Latin documents into Arabic. Tadelakt is essentially a Roman cement utilizing limestone local to Marrakech. The very effective fuel for the furnace comes from the surrounding fields, a plentiful brush high in natural oils that are set aside and dried weeks in advance. The temperature is raised to about 950°C (1750°F) which is maintained for at least 24 hours under the careful supervision of an experienced baker. There of course is no thermometer. He determines the temperature by observing the color of the flame and the smell of the smoke.

The baker inspects inside the vault
After another full day of cooling the vault is broken down and carted away. If the limestone was properly baked, the stones will fall to powder by lightly spraying with water. The reaction is quick producing a good amount of heat, though not as much as a pure quicklime. Finally it is put through a series of screeds to remove over or under cooked chunks. This is typically done in the open air by two men holding and shaking a large manual screed approximately 3' x 8' with an assistant throwing plaster on it. The Tadelakt lime will stay highly active if quickly packaged and stored to prevent carbonation with the air.

Application

Application of Tadelakt is a multi-step process. The essence of skillfully applied Tadelakt is timing. Understanding when to do each step is something that is difficult to describe and requires firsthand experience. With Tadelakt, there are many ways to achieve the same result, depending on the tools and materials that are being used. This description is meant to describe the Tadelakt process as it is done traditionally in Marrakech.

Tools

courtesy of Franco Saladino
The traditional tools used in Morocco, are very simple. A large masons trowel is used for mixing. A bucket of water and large brush are used to wet the walls. The masons trowel is used in combination with the “Taloche”, a wood float that can be used as a hawk or a trowel to hold or apply the material. Once the material has been applied, the wood float is used to flatten and fill the surface. The masons trowel is then used to initially smooth the surface. The “Galet” is a hard river stone that is usually flat on one side and polished smooth. Various pieces of plastic are used for a final smoothing. One is a stiff flat piece with a polished edge. Also used is folded up sheet plastic that is used for smoothing round shapes.

Mixing

The Tadelakt is traditionally mixed very simply by hand. The material is screened through a fine screen to remove the largest pieces of aggregate. The powder is added to the water and mixed well with the mason’s trowel. The material is mixed surprisingly thin to account for the relatively high suction of traditional substrates. Pigment is added dry after the Tadelakt is mixed. The dry pigment is sprinkled with a little water then thoroughly mixed in.

Application

The first step in the application process is to test the absorption of the background. Tadelakt traditionally was applied to highly absorbent backgrounds such as thick earth, lime, or cement walls. To reduce the suction, a small amount of water is dashed onto the surface. Before large scale application, a small dab of material is applied to the wall to ensure that the background is taking up the water at the proper rate. The Tadelakt is initially applied in multiple thin layers one after another to achieve a final thickness of about 4-6 mm . The masons trowel is used to apply and the wood float is used as a hawk to hold the material. Alternatively, the wood float can be used as a trowel with the masons trowel used to scoop the plaster onto the float.

During application care is taken to try and get a fairly even and level surface. After a short time, the wooden float is scoured over the surface to fill and flatten. High spots are ground down and low spots are filled. Another important aspect of this step is to crush in all of the bigger sand grains and to bring the fines to the surface. The next step is to smooth the surface of the Tadelakt with the mason’s trowel after the thickness of the plaster has dried until just the surface is workable. Again a little water can be sprinkled if the surface is too dry. The plastic skimmer can also be used to smooth the surface.

Ryan Chivers polishing with the "galet"
After a further period of drying, the Tadelakt is ready to be polished with the stone. This process can begin when the surface is just barely movable. Polishing should continue as the surface dries until a smooth surface has been achieved. At this point, any small holes or imperfections can be filled with the trowel or the plastic skimmer and rubbed smooth with the stone. When the stone polishing is complete, and the surface has dried enough to have a slight tack, it gets burnished with the plastic skimmer. This is done horizontally, then vertically. The plastic gives the surface a high gloss and is the final step until the soap is applied the next day.

The Tadelakt is left to dry for 12 hours or more, usually overnight. The surface is thoroughly coated with soapy water and immediately polished with the stone. The surface is polished again with the stone. At this point, firm pressure is used to consolidate the surface. After the whole surface has been polished, and most of the soap has been rubbed in, a soft dry cloth can be used to wipe off any excess soap. It is common to apply several subsequent layers of soapy water with a brush in the days following the application. This step aids curing and carbonation and adds a layer of luster to the Tadelakt. It is also common to apply a coating of wax after a 30 day carbonation period.

Concluding Thoughts

Much of the excitement surrounding Tadelakt stems not only from its intrinsic beauty but also its waterproofing characteristics. I always like to caution folks though that Tadelakt is a veneer plaster application and can’t possibly be waterproof by itself. Rather, it forms the last exposed surface of a waterproof system. In Morocco and even in the EU terracotta, brick or cement block with a brown coat of hydraulic lime or cement stucco might serve as a typical support. However, timber frame construction is the norm in the US so it is important to make certain that the framing is very secure with no flex or movement and the substrate is appropriate. Cement boards or metal lath are well supported solutions adopted for tile and stone that can also be useful for Tadelakt.

I can’t say enough good things about the Moroccan “Savon Noir”, black soap. It is a natural olive based soap sold by the kilo in the bazaars and used for everything from personal hygiene (my shampoo) to all manner of washing in the home. It comes as a thick paste but easily emulsifies in water if mixed and left overnight. As Ryan mentions it is very important to apply the soap the next day before the Tadelakt begins to carbonate. The action of the galet rubbing the soap into the Tadelakt deeply impregnates the plaster. The soap does not form a film like wax, however. The alkalinity of the lime chemically reacts with the soap to form another mineral, calcium stearate (think soap scum!). The surface becomes highly resistant to liquid water, scratch resistant and harder than cured lime yet still breathable to water vapor.

This January Ryan Chivers will be taking the lead in instructing a two day workshop at Prima Terra Plasters who are importing authentic Tadelakt from Morocco (http://www.facebook.com/events/485838111460505/). I’ll be there as an assistant and hope to see some of you as well!

This article was coauthored by Patrick Webb and Ryan Chivers